The Earth Science Women’s Network, Association for Women Geoscientists and the American Geophysical Union are partnering to address the problem of sexual harassment in the earth, space and environmental sciences with a four-year, $1.1 million grant from the National Science Foundation ADVANCE program. A primary goal of the project is to improve work climate conditions by developing bystander intervention workshops for department heads, chairs, faculty and grad students to appropriately respond to and prevent sexual harassment on campus and in the field as well as include awareness and prevention training of sexual and other types of harassment in the teaching of ethical conduct in research.
Many factors play into the decisions of women to leave science, including overt and subtle forms of gender and racial discrimination. The proposed work addresses three related barriers to the retention of women in the geosciences: (1) Hostile climate due to the prevalence of sexual harassment, especially in areas with field training and research; (2) Perceptions that sexual harassment is infrequent and affects few individuals; and (3) Perceived and real lack of resources for responding to sexual harassment.
We propose to raise awareness of the pervasiveness of sexual harassment through development of tested workshops for department heads, chairs, and faculty and a survey of the geoscience community. Our work will address the culture of academic geoscience by empowering the earth and space science community to stop and prevent sexual harassment by developing strategies of bystander intervention and disseminating these through in-person and online workshops. We will enhance ethics training of current and future geoscientists by producing teaching modules that include sexual harassment as research misconduct. We will partner with professional societies for national dissemination and sustainability.
The aims of our research are to:
- Develop and test sexual harassment bystander intervention training programs with geoscience-relevant scenarios and that incorporate experiences of diverse women.
- Develop teaching modules on sexual harassment for geoscience faculty and instructors to use in research ethics training courses.
- Disseminate training workshops, webinars, and teaching modules via partnership with professional societies for sustainability.
- Develop a sustainable model that can be transferred to other STEM disciplines.
We focus on geoscientists because it is one of the least diverse of the science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) fields. Little data on how sexual harassment affects women with intersectional identities in the geosciences leads to a lack of awareness of the unique challenges faced by minority women and a lack of appropriate institutional response. The geosciences have an additional challenge: research and training at off-campus field sites where access to support networks and clear guidelines for conduct are weakened or absent.
Erika Marín-Spiotta (Lead PI) is Treasurer and Leadership Board Member of the Earth Science Women’s Network and Associate Prof. of Geography, UW-Madison. She is a NSF CAREER awardee and past co-PI of an ADVANCE PAID award to support early-career women geoscientists. She is the 2016 AGU Sulzman Awardee for Excellence in Education and Mentoring. She was on the Steering Committee of the AGU SH workshop and serves on AGU’s Ethics Task Force.
Billy Williams is Director of Science and Vice President, Ethics, Diversity and Inclusion at the American Geophysical Union. As a member of the senior team reporting to the Executive Director/CEO, he works with the Council in designing and implementing AGU’s scientific agenda and work plan. Prior to AGU, Williams was a senior program officer at the National Academy of Sciences and Global Research and Development Director at the Dow Chemical Company.
Blair Schneider is Past-President and on the Executive Committee of the Association for Women Geoscientists. She has a Ph.D. in Geophysics from the Univ. of Kansas and is currently the TRESTLE Program Manager, KU Center for Teaching Excellence. She serves on the Women’s Network Committee for the Society of Exploration Geophysicists (SEG) and is the AWG liaison for the American Association of Petroleum Geologists (AAPG) Prowess group.
Meredith Hastings is Vice President on the Leadership Board of ESWN and Associate Prof. of Earth, Environmental, and Planetary Sciences, Brown Univ. She is an NSF CAREER awardee, and served as lead PI on a NSF ADVANCE PAID award to support early career women geoscientists. She has organized and facilitated professional skills’ workshops for early career geoscientists. She is a recipient of AGU’s Atmospheric Science Ascent Award and was also recently named one of Insight into Diversity’s 100 Most Inspiring Women in STEM.
Asmeret Asefaw Berhe is on the ESWN Leadership Board and an Associate Prof. of Natural Resources, Univ. of California, Merced. She is a NSF CAREER awardee, past PI and co-PI of NSF grants that supported participation of women and underrepresented minorities in research and outreach. She works with the Lawrence Hall of Science to develop earth and environmental science curriculum for K-12 education, and is currently assisting in development of the next generation standards for junior high school science education in California.
Rebecca Barnes is on the Leadership Board of the ESWN and an Assistant Prof. in the Environmental Program at Colorado College. Barnes has contributed to and facilitated professional development skills’ workshops for early career scientists on university campuses and at professional society meetings. She is currently co-PI on a NSF-funded, Improving Undergraduate STEM Education project to improve the recruitment and persistence of women in the geosciences.
Allison Mattheis is Assistant Prof. of Applied and Advanced Studies in Education at California State Univ., Los Angeles. She is a lead researcher of the national Queer in STEM project. She has experience designing and implementing professional development programs on curriculum improvement. She teaches in programs to prepare teachers, K-12 leaders, and higher education professionals as social justice advocates in diverse learning spaces and conducts Safe Zone trainings.
Students on the project:
Sunita Nandihalli is a Masters student in Counseling Psychology at UW-Madison.
Haley Burkhardt is a Masters student in Biological Anthropology at UW-Madison.
Megan Murphy is a Biology and Dance undergraduate student at UW-Madison.
Christine Pribbenow (Internal Evaluator) is Senior Scientist at the Wisconsin Center for Education Research at UW-Madison and Director of the LEAD Center (Learning through Evaluation, Adaptation, and Dissemination), whose mission is to advance the quality of teaching and learning by evaluating the effectiveness of educational innovations, policies, and practices in higher education. Pribbenow has extensive experience in the development, implementation, evaluation, and dissemination of faculty training about departmental climate on gender and racial bias.
Christine Fabian is an Assistant Researcher at the Wisconsin Center for Education Research at UW-Madison with expertise in evaluation research for grants and programs related to higher education. Her evaluation experience involves community education programs, NSF funded scholarships, undergraduate research experiences, first-year student engagement activities, and women in STEM.
Laura Sample McMeeking (External Evaluator), Associate Director of the Colorado State Univ. STEM Center has a M.S. in Atmospheric Science and a Ph.D. in Education Research Methods. She has more than 10 years experience evaluating large-scale federally funded projects. Her research focuses on STEM professional development for faculty, postdoctoral researchers, and students. Her work aims to understand how professional development leads to changes in knowledge, attitudes, skills, and behaviors with regards to instructional and professional practice.
Science Education and Research Center at Carleton College will develop, implement and host our project website for dissemination and sustainability, participate in some of the workshops, and help prepare workshop materials. SERC provides a resource for educational programs across the United States providing professional development, dissemination, and web services.
The National Association for Geoscience Teachers (NAGT) educational review team will advise on web-based module and review content for incorporation into Teach the Earth and NAGT’s leader training program.
Anne Egger is Associate Prof. of Geological Sciences and Science Education at Central Washington Univ. She is currently President of NAGT, where she also chairs the professional development planning committee, has led faculty workshops, and developed the review process for project sites for Teach the Earth. She is senior editor of Visionlearning, which creates freely available, online teaching resources that highlight the process of science, including research ethics.
Aisha Morris is Director of the Research Experiences in Solid Earth Sciences for Students and Education Specialist, UNAVCO, Inc. and NAGT Executive Committee Member. She has a PhD in Geology and Geophysics and served on the Advisory Committee of the Continental Scientific Drilling Coordination Office Outreach, Diversity, and Education Committee. Morris is also on the ESWN Leadership Board.
Jennifer Wenner is Prof. of Geology at UW-Oshkosh and NAGT Executive Committee Member. She served as co-PI on two NSF CCLI grants and has worked with SERC on several educational programs, including leading workshops for faculty on teaching quantitative skills.
- “UW geographer leads initiative against sexual harassment” by Greg Bump. Published 7 August 2017 wisc.edu/uw-geographer-leads-initiative-against-sexual-harassment/
- “NSF Grant: AGU and partners aim at gender issues in geoscience.” Eos, 98, https://doi.org/10.1029/2017EO079495. By Billy Williams. Published on 10 August 2017.
- “Rebecca Barnes part of NSF grant to fight sexual harassment.” Published on 14 August 2017 https://www.coloradocollege.edu/newsevents/newsroom/rebecca-barnes-part-of-nsf-grant-to-fight-sexual-harassment#.Wc0WdtOGNTY
- “Earth scientist targets sexual harassment with NSF grant” by Jason Alvarez. Published online 29 August 2017 http://www.ucmerced.edu/news/2017/earth-scientist-targets-sexual-harassment-nsf-grant
- “Q&A: Erika Marin-Spiotta is working to develop strategies to fight sexual harassment in science” The Cap Times Published on 4 September 2017 http://host.madison.com/ct/news/local/education/university/q-a-erika-marin-spiotta-is-working-to- develop-strategies/article_227b12d1-bf55-516d-aba3-5313de53fcd5.html
- “UW Professor addresses sexual harassment in STEM fields.” by Susan Maloney. The Badger Herald. Published online 5 September 2017 https://badgerherald.com/news/2017/09/05/uw-professor-addresses-sexual-harassment-in-stem-fields/
- “Scientists’ sexual-harassment case sparks protests at University of Rochester” by Alexandra Witze. Nature News Published online 14 September 2017 https://www.nature.com/news/scientists-sexual-harassment-case-sparks-protests-at-university-of-rochester-1.22620
- “Brown professor part of new anti-sexual harassment initiative in Earth science fields” by Kevin Stacey https://news.brown.edu/articles/2017/09/harassment Published online 19 September 2017
- “Professor Becca Barnes, fighting sexual hassment in STEM” by Sophia Skelly. The Catalyst. Published online 29 September 2017 http://catalystnewspaper.com/news/professor-becca-barnes-fighting-sexual-harassment-stem/
- “Disturbing allegations of sexual harassment in Antarctica leveled at noted scientist” by Meredith Wadman. Science. Published online 6 October 2017. https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/10/disturbing-allegations-sexual-harassment-antarctica-leveled-noted-scientist
- “Cal State LA faculty member from Silver Lake collaborates with national team to prevent sexual harassment” http://thesilverlakenews.com/cal-state-la-faculty-member-from-silver-lake-collaborates-with-national-team-to-prevent-sexual-harassment/
Related work prior to this NSF award:
- AGU Board of Directors recently approved Ethics Task Force recommendations to include harassment, bullying and discrimination. Billy Williams co-led the Ethics Task Force and Marin-Spiotta was a member. https://eos.org/agu-news/agu-revises-its-integrity-and-ethics-policy
- Science magazine article on AGU’s new code of ethics: https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/09/scientific-society-defines-sexual-harassment-scientific-misconduct
- Scientific societies speak out against sexual harassment– press release of a NSF-funded workshop convened by the American Geophysical Union and co-sponsored by the American Association for the Advancement of Science, American Chemical Society, American Geosciences Institute, Association for Women Geoscientists, and Earth Science Women’s Network. Billy Williams was Lead PI on the grant for the workshop and Erika Marin-Spiotta and Blair Schneider were on the steering committee that organized and led the workshop. Check out the first product of the workshop, an AGU website with resources for dealing with sexual harassment. (9/12/16) More on the workshop here. (9/20/16)
- Marin-Spiotta and Schneider co-authored an invited opinion piece on the role of scientific societies in dealing with the problem of sexual harassment, published in EOS. (1/28/16)
- AGU holds a special town hall on sexual harassment at the 2015 Fall Meeting organized by Billy Williams, Blair Schneider and Erika Marin-Spiotta. http://fromtheprow.agu.org/sexual-harassment-and-scientific-community/
- Marin-Spiotta was quoted in a piece in Nature on field safety. This article has some very good tips for staying safe in the field and ensuring fieldwork is a welcoming environment for everyone. (3/12/15)
This work is funded by NSF Award # 1725879 “ADVANCE Partnership: From the Classroom to the Field: Improving the Workplace in the Geosciences.” The goals of the ADVANCE program are (1) to develop systemic approaches to increase the representation and advancement of women in academic STEM careers; (2) to develop innovative and sustainable ways to promote gender equity that involve both men and women in the STEM academic workforce; and (3) to contribute to the research knowledge base on gender equity and the intersection of gender and other identities in STEM academic careers. The ADVANCE program contributes to the development of a more diverse science and engineering workforce because of the focus on equity for STEM academic faculty who are educating, training, and mentoring undergraduate and graduate students and postdoctoral scholars.